Faith Hill, the country music superstar, was obviously angry when she lost to new-on-the-scene Carrie Underwood for the female vocalist of the year award on Monday night at the Country Music Association Awards in Nashville.

While nominees like Martina McBride, Sara Evans, and Gretchen Wilson stuck with the losing graciously protocol after Underwood’s name was announced at the ceremony, Hill abruptly turned to the cameras and shouted a flabbergasted “WHAT?”